Fifty years ago, C. P. Snow lamented in his famous lecture, The Two Cultures, that there was a rift in understanding between the sciences and the humanities. He noted that ignorance of the laws of thermodynamics is akin to never having read a work of Shakespeare, and that such scientific illiteracy could prove harmful to society. How can our leaders solve our problems if they don't understand them?
Sunday, May 17, 2009
So it was with great interest that I went last Saturday (9 May) to the New York Academy of Sciences, at the top of the world, to attended a conference exploring the current state of the Two Cultures and what could be done about it. There were many fascinating people there.
The 192 year old NY Academy of Sciences now resides in the gleaming new building at 7 World Trade Center. Forty stories up, there is a panoramic view of Manhattan, and an overlook on the unimproved hole of ground zero.
Actually, one feels the presence of 9/11 as soon as one steps in the elevator. Each wall of the elevator is roughly polished metal, so that one's reflection is distorted as it is bounced back and forth, and one is surrounded by ghostly images.
There were two main topics discussed: the nature of the divide between scientists and nonscientists (both in the humanities and the general public), and what one could do to bridge the gap.
E. O. Wilson, the famous biologist, described his idea of consilience, and argued that the walls between fields were illusions because of the interdisciplinary bridges which already exist. He is a hardcore reductionist who believes that complex sociological behavior can be mapped to chemical reactions in the brain. On the other hand, the historian Ann Blair argued that having walls between fields was important so they can flourish independently.
But most of the day was spent discussing how to bridge the gap between science and the larger society (such as you, dear reader). There was a panel on "How to more effectively communicate science issues to the public," with the executive producer of Nova, Paula Apsell, and the host of Science Friday, Ira Flatow. There was a panel on science and politics with the founders of Science Debate 2008. And there was a concluding keynote address by Segway inventor, Dean Kamen. I have to say that I was impressed with his organization, FIRST, which sponsors a robot competition that makes science cool for kids. In just 20 years, it has gone from a handful of people, to something which won't fit in the Houston Astrodome!
Science is increasingly important for our society. For democracy to work in such an environment, it is essential that the average citizen be at least somewhat scientifically literate. For example, everyone should have some vague idea why a perpetual motion machine can't work (thermodynamics says, "there ain't no free lunch"). So I hope we can all work on bridges of understanding between ourselves.